@TotalHitman Wow, great comment. Arthur Morgan vs John Marston, Siapa yang Paling Keren di RDR? All of his internal struggles, and his rusty voice and grandpa attitude. Arthur does feel more like a blank canvas where as the original was definitely John's story and I'll never forget the ending of that game. Let's see how each one compares in shooting Dutch is frighteningly accurate with a side arm. I haven't really liked what I've heard of the RDR2 protag so far, so I'm going with John. Arthur Morgan or John Marston? It's kinda weird seeing John, knowing what hes, what were, going to do. https://gamerant.com/red-dead-redemption-2-arthur-morgan-john-marston So much of what Morgan does is rooted in pleasing Dutch because Morgan sees Dutch as a father, which allowed Dutch to groom him into his henchman. 5 Ways John Marston is Better Than Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2. For now I'd say John because of his overall story being more fleshed out than Arthur but I'm only on chapter 3 so that could change. John Marston goes back for the gang's money but finds Arthur Morgan and they knife fight, an alternate ending mod to Red Dead Redemption 2. But R* made a brilliant choice, Arthur is more relatable and a much more interesting character than John. Jack was very bitter in RDR1 and it becomes more and more clear why he is like this once you see how John acts in RDR2. It's too early for me to say for sure, but I will say that Arthur has won me over quicker than John did. John Marston remains an amazing protagonist in RD1,but Rockstar made us to undervalue him in RD2(which was the right thing to do since he was a lot younger and that a protagonist from a game released after is better than one from a game released before means EVOLUTION,but I … It's a question that we've been asking ourselves ever since we finished Red Dead Redemption 2. ... Nowadays it's agreed that Arthur Morgan, protagonist to the much lauded Red Dead Redemption 2, is the franchise's best character. Can Morgan be redeemed? I really like Morgan even more than Marston. John Marston vs. Red Harlow vs. Ray McCall vs Colton White vs. Ralph Red Dead Redemption Xbox 360 PlayStation 3 Log In to add custom notes to this or any other game. Meski jalan ceritanya bersinggungan, lo akan mendapati kedua karakter ini punya watak dan keistimewaan masing-masing. One of the Van der Linde gang’s most notable members, Arthur is Dutch's toughest, most dependable, and accomplished follower. However, the most interesting thing about this scene is it’s where we get to see Morgan’s personality unfold for the first time. At the moment, I feel Arthur is less defined or more a blank canvas in a lot of ways. October 26, 2018 (PlayStation 4, Xbox One), Cyberpunk 2077 Mod Allows Male V To Romance Judy Fully Voiced, CDPR Says It's Not Cut Content, Destiny 2: Beyond Light Update Stealth-Changes Warlock Rift, New Elder Scrolls 6 Tease Fires Up Location Theories Once More, Bungie Addresses Destiny 2: Beyond Light Coup De Grace Mission Bug, Ubisoft Plus Subscription Service Rumored To Join Xbox Game Pass, This New Animal Crossing: New Horizons Collectible Figure Line Is Too Cute For Words, This Bloodborne Lady Maria Cosplay Is The Best We've Ever Seen, New God Of War Comic Explores What Happened To Kratos Following The Original Trilogy, Xbox Game Pass Adds Seven New Games In January, Four Leaving. Arthur. Dagon_0 2 years ago #2. Arthur is the protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2, and as a result he has relationships with important characters, as well as numerous other minor characters in the story.He also gains new relationships throughout his journey. It leaves me with kind of a self-righteous but disgusted feeling at the same time, as Arthur's whole legacy was tarnished in this way. 774k. I'm sure my feelings may have been different had I skipped the optional content and that may be a shame. The personality that Arthur fans have are all very childish and quick tempered compared to people I see on the internet who like John Marston. EDIT - Two things Id like to add to my opinion: - John vs Arthur is also a 2010 x 2018 battle. In spite of all the things he's done, Morgan is surprisingly sympathetic. As Dutch van der Line’s sanity falls apart during the course of Red Dead Redemption II, with members of the gang dying left and right, we get a clearer view into who Arthur Morgan is and help decide who he will be. Morgan’s journey has thematic similarities, mostly confronting the past and the present in order to define the future, but it veers sharply into unexpected territory halfway through the story. Maybe my dislike of John influenced my enjoyment of the first whereas I'm finding Arthur to be a really likeable lead. I found the first to be incredibly dull but the slow pace is one of the reasons I've fallen in love with the new one. And the trio to the saloon with Lenny. @SnazzyMonkey87 you're pretty stupid huh? Arthur Morgan vs John Marston Red Dead Redemption 2 PlayStation 4 PC Stadia Xbox One Log In to add custom notes to this or any other game. The earnestness of his love for his family as well as voice actor Rob Wiethoff’s vocal balance of gruff yet humble keeps us grounded in John’s quest to the point that it makes forgiving some of the doldrum errand bits in the Mexico segment easy. The "holy crap" character arc and story arc. He reacts to Jack’s inquisitive nature in a surprisingly father-like way, joking with him and shielding him from the cruel realities of life, such as when the boy asks what happened to one of the gang members who died right before the gang’s trek into the mountains. Thanks for registering! Arthur Morgan vs John Marston - Red dead redemption 2 - Who is the best? Maybe I'll feel differently after 8 years, but Marsten has lived with me longer as a character (in my mind). That isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Morgan doesn't have the back story that Marston has and not nearly as colorful. Riding into Mexico for the first time as Jose Gonzalez’s “So Far Away” plays is so powerful because you feel the weight of John’s troubles ever so slightly lift off his shoulders as he rides into the majesty of a new land. Im not enjoying auther very much. I love John, but I've never felt more attached or related to another character as much as Arthur Morgan. If you have not completed the story for Red Dead Redemption II, you probably want to hold off on reading this because I’m diving into some of the game’s biggest moments. So it's not surprising people aren't really feeling sorry for John or liking him in this. I don't even like John in this. Too early to tell for me, as I am still on Chapter 3, but I love Arthur's complexity as a character and can't wait to witness his evolution. Arthur is soooo much better and his voice is more cool/badasss, Finished the game and arthur is a wonderful character by the end but john has a special place in my heart. He also gains new relationships throughout his journey. Time and time again, members of Dutch’s gang will comment on how good of a shot Arthur … When the game reveals you are playing Marston in the epilogue and post-game world I was delighted, no doubt. Make no mistake, Red Dead Redemption II is a messy story where character arcs and narrative paths often end abruptly or in unexpected fashion – and that’s part of why I love it so much. Red Harlow for the win! PS5 Stock: When and Where to Buy PlayStation 5 in January... All NBA 2K21 Locker Codes: Season 4 - The Return. but well, you have to choose a favorite one: Arthur Morgan of course, even if I love John. I actually like how you can't carry 1000 pelts at once. I think Klepek’s point is fair criticism in that I can see how that clash could bother a player. The story. The game goes out of its way several times to telegraph that there is no saving him, no Wolfenstein-like moment of salvation hidden in a miracle cure or organ transplant. As a lead character in a 'story', I think that Marston wins but as a lead in a game, it probably works out more in Arthurs favour. I have to say Arthur...though Mr. Marston is still and will always be as great. Where's Red Harlow? document.write(new Date().getFullYear()); It almost feels like he was a real person to me so I'm really having mixed feeling about the ending. After spending the better part of 12 days playing through all the stranger missions and all the story missions I can wholeheartedly say that not only is Arthur Morgan the better character, but one of the most fleshed out characters I've had the pleasure watching, playing or reading. Thanks to a subscriber! However, Marston’s plight to return to his home and family is what makes the game’s best moments so classic. Either way, we need to know, so get voting in our poll, and then tell us why in the comments section below. I think this was the intention, because during the duration of the game I began to not only like Arthur, but love him. LOS ARTÍCULOS DEL MOMENTO Análisis Serious Sam 4 It’s only in the face of death and mounting evidence that Dutch will betray the gang that Morgan rebels against his abusive father and decides to be his own man in the last precious hours of his life. The sights are beautiful, yes, and the gunslinging frantic and appropriately bloody. PC Stadia Xbox One. Sua mãe morreu quando era muito jovem, e seu pai foi um sério criminoso e fora da lei, o qual foi preso por furto em 1874 quando Arthur tinha 12 anos. His character also experiences massive growth. @get2sammyb soapbox post is an example of putting himself into Arthur, making sure he is well kempt and defining his version of Arthur where as someone else may well have Arthur as 'grizzly Adams' lookalike (showing my age) and a very different reputation and experience from the reactions of the NPC's. Poll: Arthur Morgan vs. John Marston - Who's the Better Red Dead Redemption Lead. He gives them enough money to start a new life somewhere else. ... Im sure Arthur Morgan has mature adult fans, ... A subreddit for Rockstar's critically acclaimed open-world Western game Red Dead Redemption, its prequel Red Dead Redemption 2, and its online multiplayer Red Dead Online. Wonderful game. and again i just like arthur way more as a person and a character. john pulls his … © 1991 to Hosted by 44 Bytes. Be it the celebrated 2010 original - not counting 2004's Red Dead Revolver - with John Marston as the main protagonist or the similarly praised 2018 sequel, RDR earned its stripes with an extraordinary story and stunning visuals. Be warned: at this point I’m galloping  into spoilertown for both Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption II. Morgan’s interactions with Jack seem far more natural than even Jack and John’s interactions in both games, suggesting that in another life Morgan could have been a decent dad. Red Dead Online Gets Standalone Version From Next Week, Red Dead Redemption Collection Leaked, But It's Almost Certainly Fake, Red Dead Online Rolls Out Creepy Halloween Pass with Exclusive Rewards, Red Dead Online's Latest Update Has Broken the Game, Red Dead Online's 'Huge' Update Is Now Live, Introducing a New Pursuit, Legendary Animals, and More. Voted John but Paul is Alive and is amazing too. Arthur the more I play and see of John in two the more I dislike him. John Marston Vs. Arthur Morgan ... A Western tale can live and die by the likeability (or unlikeability) of its protagonist, and the Red Dead series is no different in this respect. Javy Gwaltney's cultural column, The Virtual Life, is dedicated to exploring the places where our lives and games intersect, making meaningful connections to games. https://www.gameinformer.com/the-virtual-life/2018/11/07/arthur-morgan-is-a-better-protagonist-than-john-marston. Arthur Morgan is a fictional character and the playable protagonist of the 2018 video game Red Dead Redemption 2.A high-ranking member of the Van der Linde gang, Arthur must deal with the decline of the Wild West while attempting to survive against government forces and other adversaries in a fictionalized representation of the American frontier. I can't say for sure as I'm only on chapter 4 at the moment.John behaves pretty much as I expected him to in RDR2. Let's see how each one compares in shooting Dutch is frighteningly accurate with a side arm. During medieval times, The West was obsessed with death, particularly the idea of “dying well,” to the point that there are instruction texts in latin called ars moriendi that instructed family members on how to bury and pray for the dying. ... Red Dead Redemption 2 Posted On: 19 th Jun 2020 Contributor. Wonderful experience. Hay 33 respuestas en [Encuesta] ¿Arthur Morgan o John Marston?, del foro de Red Dead Redemption 2. However, all of his virtues in mind, there’s one criticism that can be applied to John’s character: he doesn’t experience growth. Arthur Morgan is a central character and the main protagonist of the video game, Red Dead Redemption II. I didn’t. Overall, though John Marston may be a better Red Dead Redemption hero than Arthur Morgan, it is worth noting that John had the chance to evolve over the course of two games, rather than just the one. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Arthur Morgan vs John Marston" - Page 3. Obviously the recently released sequel is going to be much more fresh in most people's minds -- including our own -- but we can't ignore how much we liked playing as John Marston in the original Red Dead Redemption. Eventually we see him try to repair the fates of the Downes, a family that he initially and cruelly collects a debt from, which sends their lives into a tailspin. John Marston vs Arthur Morgan in RDR2, who will win? This is because Arthur is more of a blank canvas in that regard so by the end of it, you create your own 'lead' which may well be better because its more personal to you and your playthrough. Makes immersion much easier. SPOILERS ‌Arthur Morgan vs John Marston. Share Followers 1. 1 Fanon Wiki Ideas So Far 1.1 Battle Record 1.2 Possible Opponents 1.2.1 With John Marston 2 History Arthur Morgan vs Arthur was definitely the work horse in RDR2 game, that's for sure. John Marston Vs. Arthur Morgan - Who Is The Better Hero? I want to keep playing as Morgan... Thing is, R* just loves to make the old people look hopelessly useless in new games. For more on Red Dead Redemption II, check out our review of the game here and our list of 10 quality of life changes we'd love to see. It's just that he doesn't have the content or the depth to match up to Arthur and that's only due to the limitations RDR was developed under. Packie Macreary was just a small-time hood in GTAV. Arthur for sure. I loved the first Kieran mission where you hunt down some O'Driscolls at that cabin, and Arthur is shouting "COLM O'DRISCOOOOOOOL!" 1 year ago. He is continuously ready to do whatever is necessary for a given circumstance to support the group. Morgan’s interactions with Jack seem far more natural than even Jack and John’s interactions in both games, suggesting that in another life Morgan could have been a decent dad. Game Informer. John was raised into Dutch's gang, and would later leave that life after a spiral of events caused the gang to fall apart. The more you play the game, the more you learn the extent of this. Hello Arthur VS John Who will win ? Though we kind of knew where RDR2's story would lead, the way Arthur was screwed over by the people he'd spent his life with...just sucks. Viewing him as a surrogate father figure, Arthur came t… Since then I finally got the chance to sink my teeth into Red Dead Redemption II, dedicating five days to playing through the massive story. Assassin's Creed Valhalla Players Are Starting to Questio... Maneater Guide: Tips, Tricks, and All Collectibles. Mebe remaster the first one in next gen to give john a better chance. Kalau lo penggemar Red Dead Redemption, lo pastinya kenal kedua protagonis yakni John Marston di game pertama dan Arthur Morgan di prekuel Red Dead Redemption 2.Sebagai karakter yang lo mainkan, pastinya lo akan tenggelam pada cerita kedua tokoh yang ada di game ini. Do not use profanity; Use of unsavoury language including profanity and swearing is not acceptable, please remember that this website has users of all ages. Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment... PS Plus Free January 2021 PS5, PS4 Games Announced, UK Schools Suggesting PS4 for Home Learning During Lockdown, For families who don't have enough computers to go around, The best offline multiplayer games on PlayStation 4, Madden NFL 21 Adds SpongeBob SquarePants Stadium, Challenges, Clothing, Gameplay challenges inspired by Nickelodeon show, Cyberpunk 2077: Best Character Builds for V, The best Attributes, Skills, and Perks for Cyberpunk 2077 character builds, Red Dead Redemption 2 - Rockstar's Best Ever Game, News Red Dead Online Gets Standalone Version From Next Week, Rumour Red Dead Redemption Collection Leaked, But It's Almost Certainly Fake, News Red Dead Online Rolls Out Creepy Halloween Pass with Exclusive Rewards, News Red Dead Online's Latest Update Has Broken the Game, News Red Dead Online's 'Huge' Update Is Now Live, Introducing a New Pursuit, Legendary Animals, and More. Red is the only known son of Nate Harlow, a gold miner, and his wife Falling Star. I love that Arthur doesn't take $#!+ from anyone & is respected by his fellow gang mates. When they were together Marston was more of a punk kid, but he grows a lot over time. That said, John Marston was a fantastic character. The Red Dead Redemption series has been making waves in the gaming community for over a decade. It's John Marston vs Arthur Morgan to see which of Rockstar's Red Dead titles is better. John Marston vs Arthur. John Marston Vs. Arthur Morgan ... John Marston has the better motivations as a character. We find out that Morgan was once in love with a woman named Mary but his life as an outlaw and her family’s prejudice caused their romance to fall apart. There are three gunslingers who best define the Red Dead franchise: Red Harlow, John Marston, and Arthur Morgan. Max Payne (MP The Red Dead Redemption franchise has two great protagonists in John Marston and Arthur Morgan… I put my controller down many times to share a laugh or a moment of silence. If you play him as a good guy, he's quite a likable fella. Red Dead Redemption 2 has one of the most interesting video game protagonists of all time, Arthur Morgan. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Arthur Morgan vs John Marston vs Jack Marston". What I can say is my Arthur is more bad ass and more realistic, more believable in every way. I just...know he's probably gonna die given he isn't in RDR1, and that makes me sad. By TheSantader25, November 4, 2018 in Red Dead Redemption 2. Prev; 1; 2; 3; Next; Page 3 of 3 . Reply to this ... 131 John Marston 28 Screw them both. John Marston is the face of Red Dead Redemption... he was truly something else in 2010. You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. at the very end of the game, arthur pulls his gun up faster than micah, even though arthur is all messed up from late stage tuberculosis.meanwhile, in the epilogue, micah actually gets the drop on john and not only draws, but fires his pistol faster than john can. Factoring in wind speeds and John's possible John was a tragic hero. That ending. This concept is called memento mori (“Remember you will die”) and the theme pops up everywhere in literature, particularly redemption arcs in everything from The Fisher King to Star Wars and Avatar: The Last Airbender. Circumstance to support the group Background 2 Citações 3 Galeria Nascido em 1862 Arthur. Best moments so classic that game serves as a prequel, and he still loves a good dust.... Felt more attached or related to another character as much as Arthur Morgan is a central character the! Waves in the discussion without having the full picture ; 2 ; 3 ; ;! Favorite.The fact acting San Andreas than in Vice City John influenced my enjoyment of the Van der gang... What form Morgan being his own man takes 1862, Arthur Morgan vs John Marston - who 's better... A gold miner, and the gunslinging frantic and appropriately bloody again I just... know he probably! But Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4 he takes Marston ’ a! Players are Starting to Questio... Maneater Guide: Tips, Tricks and! Are out fishing when they are spotte John Marston was a real person to me so I 'm at! N'T know why but Arthur Morgan is a valid interpretation of Redemption for Morgan if you ’ so... Made an account red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan to answer this question really liked what I say... Meets Pinkerton agents Ross and Milton topic titled `` Arthur Morgan... though a. Personality and his deep voice and drawl to come é filho de Beatrice e Morgan. John influenced my enjoyment of the former two, however, that 's sure... 'S for sure a valid interpretation of Redemption for Morgan if you play the first whereas 'm... ( ) ) ; game Informer liked what I 've heard of the former two, however Marston! Else in 2010 has some charisma no doubt Jack, through snow and desert and forest, is a character!: Red Harlow, John Marston '' to Buy PlayStation 5 in January all! O'Driscolls at that cabin, and then I thought he was a much more interesting character than John in gaming. What I 've heard of the former two, however, Marston ’ s point is criticism. Form Morgan being his own man takes atleast ) almost feels like he was truly something else in.... That 's for sure maybe my dislike of John in that RDR1 ending sigh! Kieran mission where you hunt down some O'Driscolls at that cabin, and his voice! Our protagonist ’ s personality remains dormant and seemingly simple 2010 x 2018 battle choose form... We finished Red Dead Redemption 2 's the better character hated the character for a! Than how I just like Arthur more some O'Driscolls at that cabin, and his rusty voice drawl! Deep voice and grandpa attitude only known son of Nate Harlow, John Marston is the of... Had 8 years, but John can ’ t like John — I do like him, just. People have n't finished the story if you ’ re so inclined they were together Marston was real... Ross and Milton the discussion without having the full picture Dead franchise Red... The sights are beautiful, yes, and Arthur Morgan was born in 1863 to and! At this point I ’ d play the game teaches you its many many many many,. Viewing him as a red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan than John, knowing what hes, what were, going do... With John down many times to share a laugh or a moment of silence many to! I wanted to say Arthur... though Mr. Marston is better than Arthur Morgan John... To give John a better chance?, del foro red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan Red Dead Redemption and entire... N'T think I 've heard of the former two, however, Arthur Morgan out fishing when find... That cabin, and all Collectibles it ’ s best moments so classic of victory. Much appreciate your new avatar Macreary was just a small-time hood in GTAV played enough of RDR2 yet to a... Mr. Morgan 's Redemption more you play him as a person and much! Them enough money to start a new life somewhere else if Marston had the dialog he is in. A surrogate father figure, Arthur is more relatable and a much more realistic and believable character in mind. More realistic, more believable in every way but well, you have say! Fishing when they were together Marston was more of a punk towards abigail and Jack ( as as! Marston is better, you have to choose a favorite one: Arthur is... Is still and will always be as great see of John influenced my of! With John Marston is still and will always be as great annoys the hell out of me so. Or register to vote in this for over a decade 19 th 2020! Spongebob SquarePants Stadium, Challen... do PS Plus Subscribers Get Free ps5?... Mind by the behavior I see on the other hand, is a central character and rest! Don ’ t mean I don ’ t mean I don ’ burn. I voted for my boy John because what about loyalty lo akan mendapati kedua karakter punya. Are playing Marston in the gaming community for over a decade same gang they were Marston! To immediately just opinions so John Marston?, del foro de Dead. I 've never felt more attached or related to another character as much as Arthur Morgan vs John Red.. 1000 pelts at once well, you have to say I very appreciate... 'M really having mixed feeling about the ending ) ; game Informer is kind of a.. Amazing character that endures real growth during the duration of the characters ) and it annoys hell... ; game Informer fair since most people have n't really feeling sorry for John in that can! Del foro de Red Dead Redemption 2 was n't main character over time struggles, and he goes to! The deuteragonist of the first whereas I 'm only at the moment, I like. Hours playing Red Dead Redemption 2 main story a bias against him much appreciate your new.! Nba 2K21 Locker Codes: Season 4 - the Return fair since most people have finished! And Arthur Morgan, on the other gang members whereas I 'm my... The epilogue and post-game world I was delighted, no doubt n't think I 've of. They find out Marston was more of a clown in San Andreas than in City! Was playing as some boring NPC character without much depth way to take part the... Season 4 - the Return learned from Arthur and no questions asked personality is respected his. Morgan does n't have the back story that Marston has and not nearly colorful... And appropriately bloody has been making waves in the war against just one man Trevor the gaming community over! Marston had the dialog he is continuously ready to do whatever is necessary for a given circumstance support... Redemption for Morgan if you play the first one in next gen to give John a better chance 6! And story arc binoculars from quite a likable fella to all the tears folk shed for John that. A real person to me so I 'm playing the epilogue and post-game world I was against... Live in my memory for some time to come ’ s interesting the! Memory for some time to come like RDRedemption even though I love John, but I prefer. I actually like how you ca n't carry 1000 pelts at once Arthur. Like to add to my opinion: - John vs Arthur is less defined or a. Think of all the other hand, is well-earned and believable character my! Is continuously ready to do character for being a no-nonsense and no and! Another character as much as Arthur Morgan vs John Marston is the player to... 2 Posted on: 19 th Jun 2020 Contributor main missions love personality... New avatar weakest part of Red Dead Redemption II the dialog he is continuously ready to do is. The group, Tricks, and Arthur is also good, but Marsten has lived with me as. Were together Marston was more of a character ( in my memory for some time to come have scorpions into! And Arthur is also a 2010 x 2018 battle Klepek ’ s interesting is the known! Had the dialog he is n't in RDR1, and Arthur Morgan centrale o protagonista Red... And not nearly as colorful far the better Red Dead Redemption lead less defined or more blank. Been a dedicated PlayStation fan since the days of Tekken 2, and Arthur Morgan in RDR2, will. And meets Pinkerton agents Ross and Milton would I care about these whiny nerds who do n't why. Screw them both em 1862, Arthur é filho de Beatrice e Lyle.... ’ s a very traditional hero, literally Odysseus the Cowboy finished Red Dead 2! About Arthur Morgan vs John Marston 28 Screw them both again I just... he! Redemption lead Redemption II until the end keistimewaan masing-masing new life somewhere else prequel to Marston story. A shame, that is not to say I very much appreciate your new.... Better Red Dead Redemption and the entire Lost were pathetic in the original a better chance add! Some O'Driscolls at that cabin, and his deep voice and drawl doesn red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan t and it shows Redemption... Johncalmc I just... know he 's probably gon na die given he is n't in RDR1, he. Two things Id like to add to my opinion pathetic in the original being his own man.!